May 7, 2004
The man who directed the reopening of the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq last year and trained the guards there resigned under pressure as director of the Utah Department of Corrections in 1997 after an inmate died while shackled to a restraining chair for 16 hours. The inmate, who suffered from schizophrenia, was kept naked the whole time.(Via the New York Times.) [11:54 PM]The Utah official, Lane McCotter, later became an executive of a private prison company, one of whose jails was under investigation by the Justice Department when he was sent to Iraq as part of a team of prison officials, judges, prosecutors and police chiefs picked by Attorney General John Ashcroft to rebuild the country’s criminal justice system.
They said that to congress today too, comments that these were just a few bad actors, and not at all reflective of anything else.
Mind you, I've been saying, from the beginning, that the "unlawful enemy combatant,' nonsense was a dangerous thing, even if nothing wrong is done at Gitmo... because it leads us to place the prisoners outside the realm of legal protection and so relys on nothing more than the strong moral fiber of the totality of those in charge.
Then they sent Miller to BCCP to give advice on how to make it more efficient, and had civilians (how angry I am at that, I cannot say) in cahrge of MPs, who were taking part in interrogation procedures.
We are lucky it was not worse.
I hope.
Terry
Is it just me, or are the activities by Ashcroft, Rumsfeld, Cheney, and Bush looking more and more like an orchestrated plan to undermine and destroy a country as thoroughly as possible? The U.S.
I mean, really.
And in doing so, they seem to be deliberately leaving a trail of breadcrumbs so thick and so wide that a person with an IQ of 65 and a fourth-grade education could figure it out.
Or is it just me? I mean, I feel like I'm a conspiracy nutbar. Ok. Yeah. That's your line.
Ah, but Terry, did you get how they lied today and said (after obfuscating for most of the session) that the civilians weren't in charge of the MPs, because that would be contrary to military law? It is buried in the transcript, towards the end, when they were running out of time and getting sloppier about the answers (or nonanswers). I found that interesting, knowing what you'd said in TNH's blog.
Son. Of. A. Bitch.:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4855930/
'Rumsfeld did not describe the photos, but U.S. military officials told NBC News that the unreleased images showed U.S. soldiers severely beating an Iraqi prisoner nearly to death, having sex with a female Iraqi female prisoner and “acting inappropriately with a dead body.” The officials said there was also a videotape, apparently shot by U.S. personnel, showing Iraqi guards raping young boys.'
Just blowing off some steam, eh Rush? Another "brilliant" tactic to show those A-Rabs we mean business, right?
Yeah, things are really looking up.
You know, I'm starting to think maybe Bush DESERVES a second term.
As punishment.
"Restraining chair" does not do that implement of torture justice. Even the picture doesn't. It's designed to immoblize the person placed in it and deny them the slightest movement beyond rotating their head. It makes me wonder if McCotter was chosen because of his history and not in spite of it.
I need to find a copy of the transcript.
But here is what I interpret of the situation.
The contractors work for the Army. At a minimum that means someone in the Army tels them what to look for (unless they are being asked to do full OB interrogations of everyone, and that ain't the case. If it were there would have been no need for Miller's investigatin/reccomendations).
One of the things which has been bothering me is the way "MI" is tossed out, as if the Corps was a monolithic whole. Also the fact of people referring to MI interrogation officers. There is no such beast.
Enlisted ask the question, officers tell us what to look for.
That said, the MPs are supposed to work in parallel with the interrogation unit. They do what we tell them to, in the booth, and they run the camp, outside the booth.
In the booth, we're the boss, outside the booth, we set some parameters, but those are mostly in regards to who is allowed to mix with whom, not who gets beat up and humiliated tonight (that's left to the CIA :).
So I'd like to see how things are supposed to have been run there (I really want to see Miller's report).
Terry
Guess I should have read Electrolite before posting to Making Light ...
Stefan J: Wouldn't that punishment be even worse for his administration's victims (current & in the further future, in the US & elsewhere)?
A bit like finding which schools are having the greatest difficulty doing what they need to, then cutting off all help to them.
Matt: It makes me wonder if McCotter was chosen because of his history and not in spite of it.
I’m well past the wondering point.
Click here for a picture of McCotter giving a tour to Paul Wolfowitz
I should note that lawsuits against prison facilities are very common… not necessarily an aberration… but the evidence does warrant further investigation. Surely McCotter’s job was a difficult one and the allegations are merely conjecture.. let’s not hang the guy on this.
But there his a history there… see
my post.
It is surprising that the American press and public is shocked by standard techniques used in American prisons every day. One of the reasons nobody should mourn the loss of the late, ungreat Gov. Gray Davis is that he blocked reforms or even investigations of the massively corrupt and cruel California prison system, which has spawned actual gangs of prison guards. Davis benefited substantially from contributions to his campaign by Prison Guard unions. The latest investigation is into the Youth Authority, after two kids hung themselves last year. Standard practice there: putting kids in 4 by 4 cages, starvation, forcing drugs upon them, beatings, pepperspraying subdued kids, sexual assault, etc. etc.
Abu Ghraim, far from being an aberration, is simply turning into your normal American jail, with the random tortures inflicted, now, on random Iraqis grabbed from checkpoints. What did they think was going to happen?
This, no doubt, is why the reaction from some quarters to these revelations is "What's the big deal?" It's standard operating procedure to them.
Roger,
I suppose the first part of your comment about the public and press being surprised is rhetorical because I'm sure that most people (me for one) don't think that this kind of systematic abuse is commonplace in America. I'm sure it does happen but hopefully it is rooted out fairly quickly. Call me an optimist.
Even if you are right though, I would think that with what is at stake in Iraq the Bush administration would at least try to be careful that crap like this doesn't happen if only so it doesn't hurt his re-election bid. Go figure.
"This has been a difficult few weeks," Bush said. "Yet our forces will stay on the offensive, finding and confronting the killers and terrorists who are trying to undermine the progress of democracy in Iraq."
Tried looking in a mirror, George?
(Real e-mail addresses and URLs only, please.)
“Peace means something different from ‘not fighting’. Those aren’t peace advocates, they're ‘stop fighting’ advocates. Peace is an active and complex thing and sometimes fighting is part of what it takes to get it.” (Jo Walton)
“You really think that safety can be plucked from the arms of an evil deed?” (Darla, “Inside Out”)
“The whole point of society is to be less unforgiving than nature.” (Arthur D. Hlavaty)
“Just because you’re on their side doesn’t mean they’re on your side.” (Teresa Nielsen Hayden)
“History is the trade secret of science fiction.” (Ken MacLeod)
“But isn’t all of human history simultaneously a disaster novel and a celebrity gossip column?” (Anonymous LJ commenter)
“I see now that keen interest can illuminate anything, and that anything, moreover, has something worth illuminating in it, and that without that interest gates carved by Benvenuto Cellini from two diamonds would merely look chilly.” (Lord Dunsany)
“We act as though comfort and luxury were the chief requirements of life, when all that we need to make us happy is something to be enthusiastic about.” (Charles Kingsley)
“Hope has two daughters, anger and courage. They are both lovely.” (attributed to St. Augustine)
“Plot is a literary convention. Story is a force of nature.” (Teresa Nielsen Hayden)
“If there is no willingness to use force to defend civil society, it’s civil society that goes away, not force.” (Teresa Nielsen Hayden)
“Always side with the truth. It’s much bigger than you are.” (Teresa Nielsen Hayden)
“Listen, here’s the thing about politics: It’s not an expression of your moral purity and your ethics and your probity and your fond dreams of some utopian future. Progressive people constantly fail to get this.” (Tony Kushner)
“People never lie so much as after a hunt, during a war, or before an election.” (Otto von Bismarck)
“Every organization appears to be headed by secret agents of its opponents.” (Robert Conquest)
“Not forgiving is like drinking rat poison and then waiting for the rat to die.” (Anne Lamott)
“See everything, overlook a great deal, improve a little.” (John XXIII)
“You will never love art well, until you love what she mirrors better.” (John Ruskin)
“They lied to you. The Devil is not the Prince of Matter; the Devil is the arrogance of the spirit, faith without smile, truth that is never seized by doubt. The Devil is grim because he knows where he is going, and, in moving, he always returns whence he came.” (Umberto Eco, The Name of the Rose)
“Adam was but human—this explains it all. He did not want the apple for the apple’s sake, he wanted it only because it was forbidden. The mistake was in not forbidding the serpent; then he would have eaten the serpent.” (Mark Twain)
“Details are all that matters; God dwells there, and you never get to see Him if you don’t struggle to get them right.” (Stephen Jay Gould)
“Tradition is not the worship of ashes, but the preservation of fire.” (Gustav Mahler)
“But this kind of deference, this attentive listening to every remark of his, required the words he uttered to be worthy of the attention they excited—a wearing state of affairs for a man accustomed to ordinary human conversation, with its perpetual interruption, contradiction, and plain disregard. Here everything he said was right; and presently his spirits began to sink under the burden.” (Patrick O'Brian, Master and Commander)
“Hatred is a banquet until you recognize you are the main course.” (Herbert Benson)
“For a Westerner to trash Western culture is like criticizing our nitrogen/oxygen atmosphere on the grounds that it sometimes gets windy, and besides, Jupiter’s is much prettier. You may not realize its advantages until you’re trying to breathe liquid methane.” (Neal Stephenson)
“And after the fire a still small voice.” (1 Kings 19:12)
“The man who tries to make the flag an object of a single party is a greater traitor to that flag than any man who fires at it.” (Lloyd George)
“The United States behaves like a salesman with a fantastic product who tries to force people to buy it at gunpoint.” (Emma of Late Night Thoughts)
“I’m a fuzzy-headed warm-hearted liberal, and I think fuzzy-headed warm-hearted liberalism is an ideological stance that needs defending—if necessary, with a hob-nailed boot-kick to the bollocks of budding totalitarianism.” (Charles Stross)
“The real test of any claim about freedom, I’ve decided, is how far you’re willing to go in letting people be wrong about it.” (Bruce Baugh)
“As with bad breath, ideology is always what the other person has.” (Terry Eagleton)
“Only he who in the face of all this can say ‘In spite of all!’ has the calling for politics.” (Max Weber)
“No, it's not fair. You’re in the wrong universe for fair.” (John Scalzi)
“Skepticism is the worst form of gullibility.” (John “adamsj” Adams)
“The Reign of Sin is more universal, the influence of unconscious error is less, than historians tell us.” (Lord Acton)
“Tomorrow never happens. It’s all the same fucking day, man.” (Janis Joplin)
“No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better.” (Samuel Beckett)
Hard-Hitting Moderator: Teresa Nielsen Hayden.
Comments on "Just a Few Bad Apples" Watch.: