"Genealogy: Where you confuse the dead and irritate the living."
Overall shape of our immediate ancestry
Three out of Patrick's four grandparents were born in Kentucky and spent most of their adult lives in Michigan. The fourth, his mother's mother, was born in Toronto of parents just off the boat from Cornwall, and her family moved to Michigan shortly after that. Patrick's mother's father's people, and his father's mother's people, were Appalachian merchants, farmers and laborers, a few prosperous, most not, descended from English and Scottish immigrants to the mid-Atlantic colonies. His father's father's people were the descendants of Catholic Maryland farmers who migrated to north central Kentucky in the late 1700s. Patrick has only a few known New England ancestors, all forebears of his father's mother.
Teresa is descended, through both of her mother's parents, from Mormons who became Mormon in the earliest days of Mormonism. Most of these people were, in turn, descended from well-documented (but rarely affluent) colonial-era families of the 17th and 18th centuries, the large majority of whom began in New England but a few of whom started instead in New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. Teresa's father was a convert to the Mormon church; his own paternal grandparents were first-generation immigrants from Denmark, and his maternal grandmother was the daughter of two Quebeçois who emigrated to Illinois. Teresa grew up in a large LDS family, several members of which were ardent genealogical researchers, so even in childhood she was aware of most of this -- except for the Quebec connection, which we learned about only recently.
We haven't used "double dates" in this database. Hal Bradley, who made the same decision for his own site, has a good explanation of the issues.
We haven't been as consistent about place names as we would prefer. We generally specify the country when a location is someplace other than the modern United States or Canada. Inconsistencies arise in connection with places whose names have changed, with municipalities that are in a different county (or country!) now than they were at the time of the event in question, and with places which essentially no longer exist as modern geographical entities, such as "Acadia" or "Savoy."
Notable ancestors (and a few relatives)
(1) Connecting to medieval ancestry
"There is no king who has not had a slave among his ancestors, and no slave who has not had a king among his." (Helen Keller)
"Gateway ancestor" is a term of art in modern North American genealogy, generally referring to an immigrant ancestor, usually (but not always) alive in the 17th century, who is provably descended from a large number of pre-1500 Europeans, almost all of whom are liable to have been gentry or aristocracy because those tend to be the individuals for whom older records survive. (It was only in the 1550s that England began requiring parishes to keep records of all baptisms, marriages, and burials.) The actual fact, of course, is that almost everyone in modern North America (including black people, Jews, Muslims, and members of other minority groups) is descended at some point from what Patrick calls the "Great Medieval Cloud," i.e., that aforementioned cluster of several thousand pre-1500 mostly upper-class Europeans whose biographical details are known to us. Having a known "gateway ancestor" probably doesn't mean you have more "noble blood" (a silly concept at any rate) than the random person next to you on the bus; it means only that you're one of the people lucky enough to have some idea of one of the specific paths of your descent from the Great Medieval Cloud. As this explainer demonstrates, there's absolutely nothing special about it; we really are all descended from Charlemagne. We're also all descended from millions of everyday people whose identities we'll never know.
Teresa has four canonical "gateway ancestors":
On Patrick's side, generations of Hayden family researchers, including Patrick himself, have spent a lot of energy examining Francis Heydon (Hayden, Heyden), a first-generation immigrant to Virginia and Maryland who died in 1694, and who is the earliest ancestor of the Virginia, Maryland, and Kentucky Haydens. It's been asserted since the late nineteenth century that he was the same Francis Hayden that was christened in Watford, Hertfordshire on 14 Aug 1628, and that he was a great-grandson of the armigerous Francis Heydon who married Frances Longueville. Unfortunately, there are too many inconsistencies in this narrative. There's no positive proof that the Francis who died in Maryland in 1694 is the same person who was born in Watford in 1628. And there are significant problems both with the widely-repeated idea that the immigrant Francis's father was the Edward Heydon who married Ellenor Whitehead, and with the equally-widespread idea that this Edward's father, another Edward Hayden who married a Frances Burr, was the same Edward as the eldest son of Francis Hayden who married Frances Longueville. Patrick's patrilineal descent from the original immigrant Francis has been proven by the Hayden DNA Project, but we no longer consider Francis more of a candidate for "gateway ancestor" status than any of the other possible-but-unproven candidates noted in the next several paragraphs.
Another appealing but probably false idea is that Thomas Hinton (b. 1693) of Maryland, who married Rachel Howard (b. 1700) and from whom Patrick and many other people are descended, was descended from John Hinton, M.D., physician to the family of Charles I and II, and/or his father Thomas Hinton, M.P. Both of these latter Hintons were definitely descendants of Edward III via John of Gaunt, and Gaunt's son, the churchman Henry Beaufort. And it's a matter of record that several of Thomas and John Hinton's immediate descendants were involved in the early colonization of Virginia and North Carolina. But notwithstanding the claims put forth in York Lowry Wilson's 1962 A Carolina-Virginia Genealogy, the evidence for a specific descent from those Hintons to Patrick's known Hinton forebears of Virginia, Maryland, and Kentucky seems to us to be hazy at best. Our view is that the connection is possible, but the spotty records that survive from early 17th-century Virginia are unlikely to yield a definitive answer.
Judge Edward F. Butler's vast 1997 tome, The Descendants of Thomas Pincerna, Progenitor of the Butler Family, traces a descent to Patrick's great-times-3 grandfather Christopher C. Butler (1810-1858) from the original Butler settlers of Kent Island, Maryland, who are themselves solidly proven "gateway ancestors". Unfortunately, this rests on the idea that Patrick's great-times-9 grandfather John Butler (born 1668 or 1675 in Virginia, died after 1723) was a son of Thomas Butler and Jane Baldridge, and while this is accepted by Judge Butler and some other Butler researchers, and marked as possible in Jon Stallard's 2004 Butler of Droitwich, it appears to be unproven.
Judge Butler does give this John Butler's wife as a daughter of Edward Thompson (d. 1662) by Joan, widow of the aforementioned Thomas Butler's father, gateway ancestor Thomas Butler who died before 16 Jan 1647 on Kent Island, Maryland. It's worth noting that many Butler family histories have called this Joan, whose first husband was London haberdasher Nicholas Mountstephen, "Joan Christopher"; that the proven descendants of Thomas Butler of Kent Island contain a large number of men named Christopher; and that the descendants of Patrick's aforementioned 9XG-grandfather John Butler also contain a large number of Christophers, including four in his direct line to Patrick. It's also worth noting that if Judge Butler is right about the parentage of both Patrick's 9XG-grandfather John Butler and his wife, then this John Butler would have been married to his half-aunt, which seems a bit Targaryen even for early colonial Virginia. Despite this, Patrick finds it impossible to completely dismiss the idea that his own Butler forbears are descended from or at least related to the "gateway ancestor" Butlers of Kent Island, Maryland and Westmoreland County, Virginia.
Finally, Patrick's 9X great-grandfather Henry Culpepper (1633-1675), proven by DNA testing to be the common ancestor of 80% of the Culpeppers in America, is often shown as a son of John Culpeper, baptized 26 Oct 1606 in Harrietsham, Kent, a descendant of many manorial and armigerous families. The evidence is suggestive but inconclusive; a good summary can be found at this entry at the extensive Culpepper family site. Notably, if this Henry Culpepper really turns out to be the son of this John, then Teresa and Patrick's most recent common ancestor would be recent indeed -- John Culpepper of Bedgebury, Goudhurst, Kent (1430-1480), a major figure in this late-medieval legal drama.
(2) Mayflower passengers
Teresa is descended from several of them:
William Brewster (abt 1566-1644) and his wife Mary (abt 1569-1627)
Francis Cooke (1583-1663)
Edward Fuller (1575-1621) and his unnamed wife (d. 1621)
Samuel Fuller (abt 1608-1683), son of Edward Fuller
Stephen Hopkins (1581-1644)
Giles Hopkins (1608-1689), son of Stephen Hopkins
John Tilley (1571-1621) and Joan Hurst (1568-1621)
John Howland (1591-1673) and Elizabeth Tilley (1607-1687), daughter of John Tilley and Joan Hurst
William Mullins (abt 1572-1621)
Priscilla Mullins (1602-abt 1685), William's daughter, and her future husband John Alden (abt 1598-1687)
Bonus brother-of-a-Mayflower-passenger ancestor: Teresa is also descended from Arthur Howland (abt 1600-1675), brother of John Howland. Arthur settled in Marshfield, Massachusetts some years after the founding of the Plymouth colony. Like his brother Henry, and entirely unlike their more famous brother John, Arthur was a firm Quaker, and endured the lifetime of legal penalties this brought upon him.
Bonus Mayflower genealogical nitpick: William Mullins and his daughter Priscilla were accompanied on the voyage by William's wife Alice (d. 1621), but it's not at all certain that Alice was Priscilla's mother, rather than her stepmother. Both William and Alice died in the first winter at Plymouth.
Leaving aside the Mayflower passengers, for sheer loopy diversity of descendants, Patrick's personal favorite of Teresa's early New England ancestors is the couple Isaac Stearns (1595-1671) and Mary Barker (1600-1677), whose descendants include Clara Barton, Brigham Young, Robert Goddard, Richard Nixon, Orson Scott Card, Forrest J Ackerman, Macmillan CEO John Turner Sargent Jr., and Countess Géraldine Margit Virginia Olga Mária Apponyi de Nagy-Apponyi, Queen Consort to King Zog I of Albania.
(3) Filles du roi
By 1660 or so it had become apparent that the fledgling North American colony of New France was badly short of marriageable women. To ameliorate this, between 1663 and 1673 the French government recruited respectable young women of limited prospects and, after vetting them for suitability, provided each of them with a small dowry, a chest of clothes, and one-way passage to Quebec. The approximately 800 women who made this journey became known as the "filles du roi", the "daughters of the King." Millions of modern French-Canadians can trace their descent from them, quite often from several. Teresa's fille du roi ancestors are:
Madeleine Auvray (1652 Rouen - 1734 Neuville)
Catherine Beaudin (1651 Paris - 1718 Neuville)
Marie Bonheur (1651 Bruyères-le-Châtel - 1691 Sainte-Famille)
Marie Hus (1644 Rouen - 1716 Quebec City)
Jeanne Fourrier (1651 France - 1704 Quebec)
Élizabeth Agnès Lefebvre (1655 Paris - 1725 Cap-St-Ignace)
Catherine Lemesle (1646 Rouen - 1716 Quebec City)
Élisabeth Leroy (1626 Senlis, Oise, Picardy - 1708 Quebec)
Anne Leseigneur (1649 Rouen - 1733 Chambly)
Marguerite Moitié (1646 La Rochelle - 1701 Sainte-Famille)
Françoise Pédenelle (1647 Loix - 1706 Île d'Orléans)
Anne Perrault (1647 Paris - 1688 Île d'Orléans)
Madeleine Têtu (1641 Rouen - 1703 Beauport)
(4) The Civil War
While the American Civil War was happening, most early Mormons were otherwise engaged, so Teresa has only two ancestors (that we know of) who were involved in it. Her father's great-grandfather Louis Joubert (1841-1919), immigrant from Quebec to Illinois, appears to have fought as a Union soldier in the 6th Illinois Cavalry, Company I. The 6th Illinois fought at the Battle of Port Hudson (22 May 1863); the second Battle of Franklin (30 Nov 1864); the Battle of Nashville (15 Dec 1864); and the minor engagements the Second Battle of Memphis (21 Aug 1864) and the Battle of Okolona (22 Feb 1864). And one of the few facts we know about another great-grandfather of Teresa's father, John Coston (~1835-1865; possibly also called "Joseph" and "Castin" or "Costin") is that he enlisted in Company H, Indiana 79th Infantry Regiment on 15 Aug 1862, and was mustered out on 13 Jul 1865.
(Naturally, given her large New England ancestry, Teresa has several genealogical connections to major Civil War figures. Via Henry Sherman, 1512-1590, and Agnes Perpoynt, d. 1580, she's an 8th cousin 6 times removed to Gen. William Tecumseh Sherman, 1820-1891. Via Alice Freeman, 1595-1658, and John Tompson, d. 1626, she's a 7th cousin 6 times removed to Gen. George B. McClellan, 1826-1885. Via Samuel Lathrop, 1621-1700, and Elizabeth Scudder, 1625-1700, she's a 5th cousin 6 times removed to Gen. Ulysses S. Grant, 1822-1885. Via Desire Howland, 1624-1683, and Capt. John Gorham, 1621-1675, she's a 5th cousin 5 times removed to Gen. Benjamin Butler, 1818-1893. Via Thomas Parker, 1737-1822, she's a half-1st-cousin 5 times removed to Civil War-era New Jersey governor Joel Parker, a "War Democrat" who was highly critical of the Lincoln administration. And via Joseph Loomis, 1590-1658, and Mary White, 1590-1652, she's a 5th cousin 6 times removed to the abolitionist John Brown, 1800-1859.)
Patrick has four direct ancestors who fought in the Civil War, evenly split between the Union and Confederate sides.
Great-great grandfather Jefferson Porter Workman (1835-1919), Company E, 46th Tennessee Infantry (Confederate), enlisted in October 1861 and was shortly thereafter captured at Island No. 10 and sent to Camp Douglas, Illinois. He took the oath to the US while in prison and was discharged 30 August 1862.
Great-great-great grandfather William Henderson Parker (1824-1898) was drafted as a private for a period of one year into a detachment of substitutes for the Union army. He was then mustered into Company F of the 18th Kentucky Infantry in London, Kentucky on 20 Sep 1864; he served for at least 10 months. He was discharged on 23 Jun 1865 near Louisville, Kentucky. An asthmatic when he entered the Army, subsequent to his service he had to sleep at night sitting up because lying down made him unable to breathe. A Pension Office document dated 14 Jan 1886, of which we have a photocopy, states that he was disabled by "paralysis caused by wading in water waist deep."
Great-great grandfather James S. Hayden (1836-1908) enlisted in the 4th Kentucky Infantry (Confederate) upon its organization at Bowling Green, Kentucky in September, 1861, and served in Company K. This unit had 213 men disabled at Shiloh, then was active at Baton Rouge and Jackson. Later it was assigned to Hanson's, Helm's, and J.H. Lewis' Brigade, Army of Tennessee. The 4th took an active part in the Battles of Murfreesboro and Chickamauga and saw action in the Atlanta Campaign. During the autumn of 1864 it was mounted, aided in the defense of Savannah, and ended the war in North Carolina. It reported 12 killed, 49 wounded, and 8 missing at Murfreesboro, lost twenty-one percent of the 275 engaged at Chickamauga, and totalled 335 men and 251 arms in December, 1863. The exact date of James S. Hayden's discharge is unknown to us but according to later records he served to the end of the war. Four days after his death on 4 Nov 1908, the Owensboro (Kentucky) Messenger reported a resolution passed by the Rice E. Graves Camp of Confederate Veterans: "Whereas, One more call, one more answer. J. S. Hayden, member of Rice E. Graves camp, answers to the final call and passes into the great beyond. Brave soldier and good man, always ready, both in the field of battle, or in the peaceful pursuits of life; generous in life, true to his friends, and stood by his political party to the last. When death called he was anxiously scanning the returns of the election, like the brave soldier he was. 'Oh,' he said and joined his comrades on the other side. Just a promotion, higher up in the ranks, where the boom of cannons or the strains of a soldier's life is not known. Peace to his ashes."
Great-great grandfather Henry Isaac Newton (1836-1893) enlisted in 1862 in the Union Army of the Cumberland, 12th Kentucky Cavalry. A corporal by the time the war ended, Newton was captured in Sweetwater, Tennessee in 1863 during Burnside's abortive campaign to push south and spent nearly a year in a Confederate prison. His regiment was mustered out 23 Aug 1865.
Despite their fathers' service on opposite sides, Confederate veteran James S. Hayden's son Clarence Eugene Hayden (1872-1908) married Union veteran Henry Isaac Newton's daughter Sarah Frances "Fannie" Newton (1879-1970); they were Patrick's father's paternal grandparents. Patrick remembers meeting his great-grandmother Newton on several occasions when he was a child.
Patrick thinks the Confederate rebellion was treason in defense of slavery and doesn't deserve to be ennobled with "lost cause" nostalgia; also that Reconstruction failed to go far enough, with consequences that can be clearly seen today. However, it's in the nature of history that bad causes sweep up good people, and vice versa. Those of us who haven't lived through something like the Civil War shouldn't be too confident that we'd make all the right life decisions if this kind of history happened to us.
Prior to Emancipation, the overwhelming majority of Patrick's Kentucky and Maryland ancestors owned slaves. A non-trivial number of Teresa's New England, New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania ancestors did so as well. Along with her small number of ancestors in Virginia and the Carolinas. Being interested in one's ancestors, and (inevitably) a little proud of what they weathered and what they accomplished, is no good if you don't also make note of the terrible things they did as well.
Patrick also notes the existence of the black abolitionist leader Lewis Hayden (1811-1889), who, although associated with Boston where he ran a station on the Underground Railroad and held various public offices, was in fact born into slavery in ... Lexington, Kentucky. Nothing is known of Lewis's father except that he was "sold off early," but given the surname, and the fact that there were hardly any Haydens in north-central Kentucky in or before 1811 who weren't related to Patrick, the chances that one of Patrick's relatives owned one of Lewis Hayden's forebears would seem to be extremely high.
(6) Modern celebrities
The actress and singer Florence Henderson (1934-2016), best known for playing Carol Brady on The Brady Bunch, was Patrick's second cousin once removed. His great-grandmother Sarah Francis "Fannie" Newton (1879-1970; see the "Civil War" section above) was a sister of Florence Henderson's grandmother Anna Justine Newton (1867-1936). Patrick remembers meeting his great-grandmother on several occasions, but he never met Florence Henderson.
The eighteenth-century Virginia farmer Charles Word (1710-1792) and his wife Sarah are 6X-great grandparents to Patrick, and 5X-great grandparents to William Faulkner (1897-1962), making Patrick a sixth cousin once removed to the novelist.
Patrick is also a sixth cousin once removed to baseball star Don Mattingly (b. 1961), through their shared ancestor Richard Mattingly, Sr. (1720-1783).
Through shared descent from the early Virginia settlers Matthew Howard and his wife Anne, both of whom died sometime in the 1650s, Patrick is a tenth cousin once removed to the late science fiction and fantasy writer John M. Ford (1957-2006). Through the same couple, Patrick is also an eighth cousin three times removed to the American poet Vachel Lindsay (1879-1931) and to Lindsay's third cousins, the outlaws Frank (1843-1915) and Jesse James (1847-1882). In addition, the James brothers and Vachel Lindsay were all sixth cousins to the odious Bessie Wallis Warfield, 1896-1986, Duchess of Windsor, through a pair of shared Maryland ancestors from whom Patrick is just as happy to not be descended.
Teresa is a fourth cousin three times removed to Dame Agatha Mary Clarissa Miller Christie (1890-1976), better known as Agatha Christie, through their shared ancestors John Miller (1735-1811) and Hannah Bush (1737-1816).
Teresa is a fifth cousin twice removed to Madonna Ciccone (1958- ), which is to say that Teresa's grandmother Hazel Ethel Coston (1898-1970) was a straight fifth cousin to the singer. This is a little striking, because Hazel Ethel Coston was born sixty years before Madonna, but what it reflects is "longer" generations in the latter's descent from their common ancestors, the Quebec couple François Joseph Moursin dit Lajoie (1747-bef 1823) and Marie Françoise Trudel (1752-1823).
Also through common Quebec ancestry, Teresa is a ninth cousin to Beyoncé Knowles (1981- ), through their common 9XG-grandparents Guillaume Trahan (~1601-~1685) and Madeleine Brun (b. ~1643), early settlers of the French colony of Acadia in New France.
Through two pairs of shared ancestors, Teresa is also doubly related to the poet Conrad Aiken (1889-1973) and his daughters, the novelists Joan Aiken (1924-2001) and Jane Aiken Hodge (1917-2009). Via Peter Tallman (1623-1708) and Joan Briggs, she's an eighth cousin twice removed to Conrad, while via John Briggs (1609-1690) and Sarah Cornell (d. 1661) she's his ninth cousin once removed.
Through common descent from the 17th-century immigrant (and gateway ancestor) Olive Welby (1604-1692) and her husband Henry Farwell (1605-1670), Teresa is a ninth cousin twice removed to American novelist Thomas Pynchon (b. 1937). She is also Pynchon's ninth cousin three times removed via their shared descent from Plymouth Colony leader William Brewster (1566-1644) and his wife Mary (d. 1627), and his tenth cousin three times removed via their descent from another 17th-century immigrant and gateway ancestor, Alice Freeman (1595-~1658) and her husband John Tompson (d. 1626).
Through shared ancestor William Ward (1603-1687), Teresa is an eleventh cousin to the brothers Brian (1942- ), Dennis (1944-1983), and Carl (1946-1988) Wilson, and their cousin Mike Love (1941- ). Inquiries are pending into the ancestry of Al Jardine.
Once again through shared Quebec ancestors, Teresa is a tenth cousin once removed to Hillary Clinton (1947- ), via her 10X-great grandparents Jean Guyon (1592-1663) and Matherine Robin (d. 1662). Another of this couple's descendants is Jean Chretien (1934- ), Prime Minister of Canada 1993-2003.
Finally, through that most productive of Quebec ancestors, Zacharie Cloutier (1590-1677) and his wife Xainte Dupont (1596-1680), Teresa is distantly related to a large number of other notables including Jack Kerouac, Angelina Jolie, the Dionne quintuplets, Camilla Duchess of Cornwall, and Canadian prime ministers Louis St-Laurent, Pierre Trudeau, and Justin Trudeau. You can read about Cloutier's many descendants in any number of places on the web, including the Wikipedia page about him. None of this is particularly unusual among modern people descended from early settlers of Quebec. Those first generations of immigrants to New France were a small population that kept good records, and their descendants have maintained a low level of intermarriage with the surrounding Anglo culture in the years since. Being able to trace one's relationship to multiple celebrities and politicians with French-Canadian ancestry is common among Francophone inhabitants of Quebec today.
(7) Early Latter-day Saints
Every line of Teresa's maternal ancestry contains people who joined the Latter-day Saint movement in the 1830s and 1840s, who endured the persecution that entailed, and who made the arduous journey west. The following are just a few examples chosen for particular historical interest.
Levi Gifford (1789-1860), one of the earliest General Authorities of what became the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He was baptized into the church in 1831, when it was barely a year old. He baptized Eleazar Miller, who in turn baptized Brigham Young (1801-1877). He was a participant in Zion's Camp and went on to be ordained a Seventy, called to serve in the First Quorum of the Seventy. 4XG grandfather of Teresa.
Martha McBride (1805-1901), wife of early Mormon leader Vinson Knight (1804-1842). After Knight died young, she became one of the plural wives of Knight's close friend Joseph Smith (1805-1844). Following Smith's murder, she became one of the plural wives of Heber C. Kimball (1801-1868), another major figure in the early Mormon church. She was one of the founders of the Relief Society. Her Wikipedia entry correctly observes that she "was a witness to, and in some instances a key participant in, some of the pivotal events in early Latter-day Saint history." 5X-great aunt of Teresa, being sister to Teresa's 4XG grandmother Margaret Ann McBride.
Morris Charles Phelps (1805-1875), Mormon pioneer. In 1838, as one of several persecutions he and his family endured, he was jailed in Missouri along with major Mormon founding figures Parley Pratt and King Follett, and kept for months in wrist and ankle irons. After several months, he and Pratt escaped on July 4, 1839 with the courageous assistance of Morris's first wife Laura Clark Baldwin (1807-1842). GX3 grandfather of Teresa.
Myron Nathan Crandall (1818-1860), Mormon pioneer. He and his wife Tryphena Bisbee (1819-1863) were among the founders of Springville, Utah, now a town of over 30,000 people. They were married in Nauvoo, Illinois, in a ceremony performed by Hyrum Smith, brother of Joseph Smith. GX3 grandparents of Teresa.
Not surprisingly, Teresa is also related to a number of other LDS leaders. In modern times, the closest are probably Harold Bingham Lee (1899-1973), eleventh president of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints and her third cousin twice removed; and her second cousin twice removed Boyd K. Packer (1924-2015), who eventually became President of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, some decades after ten-year-old Teresa got into a ferocious argument with him at a family gathering. Teresa also has several ancestors in common with Brigham Young, mentioned earlier; the closest are probably Deacon Simon Stone (d. 1708) and his wife Mary Whipple (1634-1720), making Teresa a fourth cousin six times removed to Young -- and an eighth cousin six times removed to Orson Scott Card, one of Young's innumerable great-grandchildren.
Finally, while he wasn't a Mormon, John Wentworth (1815-1888), a fifth cousin five times removed to Teresa, was an oddly significant figure in Mormon history. Wentworth is remembered as a two-term mayor of Chicago and a six-term member of Congress, but in 1842 he was merely the editor of the Chicago Democrat, in which capacity he wrote to LDS founder and prophet Joseph Smith with some questions on behalf of a friend, George Barstow, who was writing a history of New Hampshire. Smith responded with a letter that, among other things, set forth the first version of what became the fundamental LDS articles of faith. This document is known to Mormons as the "Wentworth Letter" and is considered to be among Smith's most significant statements of LDS belief. Tying this sidebar up with a bow, after his retirement from politics, John Wentworth spent tens of thousands of dollars compiling and publishing The Wentworth Genealogy -- English and American, a three-volume study of Wentworth ancestry which, while not without errors, stands as one of the best such self-published studies of its time. It was as part of this project that Wentworth funded Joseph Lemuel Chester's research in English parishes that first connected the original Wentworth immigrant, William Wentworth (1616-1697), to late-medieval English gentry, thus beginning the process of establishing William Wentworth as a "gateway ancestor" -- one of Teresa's four.
(8) Teresa's favorite medieval ancestors:
Geoffrey Luttrell (1276-1345) and his wife Agnes de Sutton (1288-1340), patrons of the Luttrell Psalter, which you should read about (and then look up on Google Images) right now. 20X-great grandparents of Teresa.
As alluded to earlier, the Teresa Nielsen Hayden Medieval Ancestry Trivia Lists Page includes such sections as "Magna Carta sureties," "Murderers of Thomas Becket," "Doges of Venice," and the ever-popular "All-Bloodshed All-the-Time Late Medieval Battles Appendix."
(9) A miscellany of others (post-1450)
Basil Hayden (1744-1804), Maryland farmer, distiller, and leader of a major emigration of Maryland families to then-frontier Kentucky. Supposedly the "Old Grand-Dad" on the label of the bourbon of that name, and definitely the person for whom the modern high-end "Basil Hayden" bourbon is named. But not precisely an ancestor of Patrick's; see the details at the entry for Patrick's 4X-great grandfather William Leo Hayden (1785-1867). (Short version: Patrick is descended from Basil's brother, Basil's father, Basil's wife, and Basil's wife's illegitimate son, but not from Basil himself. Weirdly, Basil and Patrick share a birthday, January 2.)
Frances Jane Coomes (1747-1816), maiden name unknown, first Anglo schoolteacher and first female physician in Kentucky. Emigrated from Maryland with her husband in 1775-76. A fascinating essay about this pioneer woman, by descendant Rita Mackin Fox, is reproduced on our entry for her. 6X-great grandmother of Patrick.
John Thimbleby (1482-1550), one of the organizers of the Lincolnshire Rising of 1536 which immediately preceded the Pilgrimage of Grace. Progenitor of a long line of grimly determined Catholic recusants named Thimbleby, oddly not including his son Richard Thimbleby (1507-1590), also an ancestor of Teresa's, who converted to the Church of England during the reign of Queen Mary in what can only be described as a display of Olympic-level contrarianism. In a letter by Richard Cromwell to his uncle Thomas Cromwell, the mauler-of-monasteries who is the subject of Hilary Mantel's novel Wolf Hall, John Thimbleby is cited as the particular ringleader in Lincolnshire that Richard would most like to capture. (In a further literary connection, this letter is itself recorded in Thomas Carlyle's 1845 Letters and Speeches of Oliver Cromwell, With Elucidations.) 14X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Rev. Thomas Stoughton (1555-1622), minister and author. His A general treatise against poperie, and in defence of the religion by publike avthoritie professed in England and other churches reformed was published at Cambridge in 1598, but only a few years later he was admonished for noncomformity and deprived of his vicarage. For the remainder of his life he lived off a series of small bequests from the wills of sympathetic nonconformists; the 1610 will of Alice Wade, for instance, describes him as "a silenced preacher." His later works include The dignitie of God's children (1610), Two profitable treatises (1616), and The Christians Sacrifice as set forth in Romans XII, 1, 2 (1622). 11X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Rev. Stephen Bachiler (1561-1656), Puritan and controversialist, early proponent of the separation of church and state. As a minister in Boston, he cast the only dissenting vote against the expulsion of Roger Williams. Early immigrant to New England, but died back in London. 10X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Rev. John Lothropp (1584-1653), Puritan clergyman, famously imprisoned in England for his beliefs, 17th-century immigrant, a founder of Barnstable, Massachusetts, and another early exponent of church-state separation. 10X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Marin Boucher (1587-1671), pioneer of early New France, ancestor to most of the Bouchers of North America. Quebec founder Samuel de Champlain left his clothing to Boucher in his will. 9X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Rev. Joseph Hull (1595-1665), relatively liberal cleric, originally Anglican, 17th-century immigrant, religious and political opponent of Plymouth Colony governor John Winthrop, and also a founder of Barnstable, Massachusetts. (Hull preached there before Lothropp arrived, but Lothropp's arrival with his large congregation is what really established the town.) 10X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Edmund Freeman (1596-1682), assistant governor of Plymouth Colony (under William Bradford), 1640-47; principal founder of the town of Sandwich. 11X-great grandfather of Teresa.
John Strong (1606-1699), one of the founders of Windsor, Connecticut and Northampton, Massachusetts. 9X-great grandfather of Teresa.
George Lawton (1607-1693), early deputy to the General Assembly of Rhode Island and original signer of the compact that founded the town of Portsmouth in that colony. After 1680 he served several terms in the electoral position of Assistant to the Governor of Rhode Island. 10X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Rev. James Noyes (1608-1656), nonconformist Anglican clergyman and emigrant to Massachusetts. A founder of Newbury, Massachusetts. His ecclesiastical writings include The Temple Measured (1647) and Moses and Aaron, or, The Rights of Church and State (1661). 9X-great grandfather of Teresa. His son Rev. James Noyes II (1640-1719), 8X-great grandfather, was one of the founding trustees of Yale.
John Briggs (1609-1690), who gave "spectral testimony" in the 1673 murder trial of Thomas Cornell, Jr. for the murder of Thomas's mother Rebecca (Briggs) Cornell. (Who may have been Briggs's sister. A good book about this whole affair is Killed Strangely: The Death of Rebecca Cornell by Elaine Forman Crane, published in 2002 by—of course—Cornell University Press.) 11X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Jeffrey Ferris (1610-1666), one of the founders of Greenwich, Connecticut, where he is memorialized in a stained-glass window at the First Congregational Church. His descendant George Washington Ferris (1859-1896) invented the Ferris wheel. 9X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Thomas Hazard (1610-1677), one of the nine original founders of Newport, Rhode Island, and an ancestor of Oliver Hazard Perry and Matthew C. Perry. 11X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Elizabeth Fones (1610-1673), early Massachusetts settler whose personal life, and wild habit of owning her own property, scandalized Puritan society. She wound up living on Long Island with her third husband. She is the subject of a quite good 1958 historical novel by Anya Seton called The Winthrop Woman. 11X-great grandmother of Teresa.
Nathaniel Dickens (1615-1692) sold, on 28 Feb 1677 to Mordecai Campannall and Moses Packechoe of Newport, Rhode Island, a parcel of land that became Touro Synagogue Cemetery, the second oldest Jewish cemetery in the United States. 10X-great grandfather of Teresa.
Thomas Stanton (1616-1677), colonial-era trader famed for his skills as a native language interpreter. Appointed official interpreter by the short-lived Dominion of New England (1686-89). One of the original settlers of Hartford, Connecticut, he was also one of the four founders of Stonington. 9X-great grandfather of Teresa.
John Crandall (1618-1676), founding settler of Westerly, Rhode Island, associate of Roger Williams. Descendant of several generations of unruly Puritan divines, including his grandfather Nicholas Crundall (1562-1605), of whom Wikipedia observes (in its article about John Crandall) that "[i]n a case brought in the Star Chamber against Nicholas Crundall, Jr., who succeeded his father as vicar [of Winterbourne, Gloucestershire], his accuser reported that Crundall resisted a constable, mockingly crying out 'The Queen's name! The Queen's name! I do not care a turd for thee nor her either.'" John Crandall was a 9X-great grandfather of Teresa and the direct paternal ancestor of Teresa's maternal grandfather Paul Leslie Crandall (1901-1987).
"Cornet" Joseph Parsons (abt 1620-1683), one of the founders of both Springfield and Northampton, Massachusetts, and his wife Mary Bliss Parsons (abt 1628-1712), who was charged twice with witchcraft, in 1656 and again in 1675, many years before the Salem witch trials. She was acquitted both times. After the first trial, her husband sued her accusers for slander and won. In a nice twist of history, Joseph and Mary Bliss Parsons were direct ancestors of an authentic modern would-be sorcerer, Marvel Whiteside "Jack" Parsons (1914-1952), early Caltech rocket scientist, co-founder of the Jet Propulsion Laboratories, and a disciple of the occultist Aleister Crowley. Joseph Parsons and Mary Bliss were 9X-great grandparents of Teresa.
Susanna North Martin (1621-1692), hung as a witch at the peak of the Salem, Massachusetts insanity. She was initially accused in 1669, but her husband sued her accusers for slander and narrowly prevailed. Her husband then died in 1686, leaving her alone and unpopular. Her 1692 trial was a travesty redeemed only by her brave refusal to be bludgeoned into guilty submission. On Tuesday, 19 Jul 1692, 70 years old and defenseless, she was murdered by the Salem authorities at Gallows Hill. She is remembered in John Greenleaf Whittier's "The Witch's Daughter" and the folk song "Susanna Martin", recorded by Touchstone, among many others. On October 31, 2001, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts formally exonerated her, which probably made somebody feel better. 10X-great grandmother of Teresa. Among her several accusers were William Brown (1615-1706), 11X-great grandfather of Teresa, and Jarvis Ring (1658-1728), Teresa's 8X-great grandfather. Bonus What Is There To Say I Can't Even: Susanna North Martin is also an 8X-great grandmother of Richard Bruce "Dick" Cheney, 46th Vice President of the United States and Lord of the Flies.
John Bowne (1627-1695), English immigrant to New Netherland, arrested on order of Peter Stuyvesant for hosting a Quaker meeting, sent to Holland for trial before the Dutch West India Company, where he exonerated himself and was sent home with a message ordering Stuyvesant to practice tolerance toward all sects. His first wife, also Teresa's ancestor, was Hannah Feake (1637-1678), daughter of Elizabeth Fones (see above) by her second husband Lt. Robert Feake (1602-1661). John Bownes's house in Flushing is still standing, the second-oldest structure in New York City, and is open to the public. 10X-great grandfather of Teresa.
The strikingly involved interconnections between many of these seventeenth-century colonists can perhaps be illustrated by the following, in which each of the boldfaced-and-italicized names is that of a direct ancestor of Teresa's mentioned above: Elizabeth Fones (1610-1655) married, first, in London, 25 Apr 1629, Henry Winthrop (1608-1630) (grandson of TNH ancestors Adam Winthrop 1548-1623, and Anne Browne, d. 1629); second, in Watertown, Massachusetts, 1632, Lt. Robert Feake (1602-1661); by him, she had Hannah Feake (1637-1678), who married John Bowne (1627-1695). Third, in Aug 1649 while arguably still married to her second husband, Elizabeth Fones married William Hallett (1615-1705). Some time after the 1655 death of Elizabeth Fones, her third husband William Hallet married Susanna Booth (d. 1675), who had previously been married to William Thorne (1618-bef. 1664); they were estranged by 1669 and divorced in 1674.
"Most of our ancestors were not perfect ladies and gentlemen. The majority of them weren't even mammals." (Robert Anton Wilson)
Teresa has a few distant genealogical connections to major figures of English literature. John Dryden (1631-1700), poet, critic, and playwright, is her seventh cousin ten times removed. As Poet Laureate of England, Dryden distinguished himself by being the only person ever dismissed from that office, when, in the great tradition of Teresa's many truculent forebears, he refused to swear an oath of allegiance in 1688 to the new king, William III. Jonathan Swift (1667-1745), satirist, poet, and author of Gulliver's Travels, is her eighth cousin eleven times removed. Her fifth cousin 14 times removed, Elizabeth Boyle (1576-1622), was the second wife of Edmund Spenser (d. 1599), author of The Faerie Queene. And Horace Walpole (1717-1797), antiquarian, art historian, and author of The Castle of Otranto, the first Gothic novel, is her tenth cousin nine times removed. The common ancestors Teresa shares with all four of these individuals are the Oxfordshire couple John Danvers (1382-1449) and Joan Bruley.
A closer connection, from the world of Jacobean letters, is to the author of A Feast for Wormes, the royalist poet Francis Quarles (1592-1644), third cousin to Teresa thirteen times removed, their common ancestors being Quarles's great-great grandparents Robert Browne (d. 1606) and Isabel Sharpe. According to a well-known anecdote that Teresa was fond of telling before she knew of her relationship to him, at one point Quarles discovered in conversation with one of the Fletchers that by total coincidence they were both working on epic-length poems describing the geography of the British Isles in terms of the human anatomy. Thus demonstrating that the phenomenon of two separate writers independently conceiving the same idea, even the same terrible idea, is less rare than one might think.
Moving into common ancestry with the 18th century, Teresa's 17XG-grandparents Thomas Gresley (~1365-~1445) and Margaret Walsh (>1421) were 9xG-grandparents of Elizabeth Jervis (1689-1752), beloved wife of Dr. Samuel Johnson.
Jane Austen (1775-1817) was a daughter of a gentry family; her mother was a great-granddaughter of James Brydges, 8th Baron Chandos (1642-1714). Most Americans with documented late-medieval gentry ancestry can trace some kind of distant cousinhood to the author of Pride and Prejudice, often through several lines. Teresa has at least seven 15th-century common ancestors with her, the closest being Edmund Roper (d. 1433), making Teresa and Jane eleventh cousins nine times removed. Interestingly, in the line from Edmund Roper to Jane, Edmund's great-grandson William Roper (d. 1578) was married to Margaret More (d. 1554), daughter of Sir Thomas More (1478-1535). William Roper wrote the first biography of his father-in-law, while his wife Margaret has been called "one of the most learned women of sixteenth-century England." Her translation of Erasmus's Precatio Dominica so impressed its author that he dedicated a subsequent work to her. They were 7X-great grandparents of Jane Austen.
Another pair of ancestors shared by Teresa and Jane Austen are John Throckmorton and Eleanor Spinney. This couple also provides a connection, albeit a recondite one, to William Shakespeare. Their 4XG-grandaughter Muriel Sheldon married Francis Clare. Francis Clare's aunt Joyce Blunt married John Combe the 2nd (d. 1558) of Stratford-upon-Avon. (Their son John Combe the 3rd died in 1614, leaving William Shakespeare £5 in his will.) John Combe the 2nd was the son of John Combe the 1st (d. 1550) and his wife Katherine. Katherine married, secondly, Adrian Quiney (d. 1553). Katherine and Adrian's great-grandson Thomas Quiney (1589-1655) married Judith Shakespeare (1585-1662), daughter of William Shakespeare and Anne Hathaway.
Of course, descent from the Great Medieval Cloud makes it hard to avoid some kind of connection to Geoffrey Chaucer (1343-1400), who aside from being one of the founders of modern English literature was also an accomplished courtier, diplomat, and civil servant, very much a member of the Cloud. (Here's Geoffrey Chaucer's entry in the History of Parliament.) Teresa's closest connection to Chaucerland is her direct descent from Thomas Swynford (1305-1361) and Nicolaa Druel, parents of Hugh Swynford (1340-1372) who was the first husband of Catherine de Roet (1350-1403), sister of Phillipa de Roet (1348-1387), wife of Chaucer. Catherine de Roet is of course better known for being the mistress of, and ultimately the third wife of, Chaucer's friend and patron John of Gaunt (1340-1399).
The couple Roger Wentworth (d. 1452) and Margery le Despenser (~1399-1478), 17X-great grandparents of Teresa, are her common ancestors with a number of persons of interest. Through their daughter Margaret Wentworth (1430-1478) and her husband William Hopton (1431-1484), they were ancestors of both Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826) and his wife Martha Wayles (1748-1782), and also of Edith Bolling (1872-1961), second wife of Woodrow Wilson (1856-1924). Through their son Philip Wentworth (1424-1464) and his wife Mary Clifford (1416-1478, a granddaughter of Henry "Hotspur" Percy), Roger and Margery were great-great grandparents of Jane Seymour (1508-1537), third wife of Henry VIII (1491-1547), and therefore also 3X-great grandparents of Edward VI (1537-1553). They were also great-great grandparents of Elizabeth Seymour (d. 1563) who married Gregory Cromwell (d. 1551), son of Thomas Cromwell (~1485-1540), looter of the heritage of Catholic England. According to Gary Boyd Roberts, Philip Wentworth and Mary Clifford are also the most recent common ancestors of Rachel Meghan Markle (b. 1981) and her husband Prince Henry of Wales (b. 1984). But much more interestingly, Philip Wentworth and Mary Clifford were 13XG-grandparents of Ada Lovelace (1815-1852), pioneer of computer programming, through their descendant, Ada's mother Anne Noel-Byron (1792-1860), 11th Baron Wentworth, and her husband George Gordon, Lord Byron (1788-1824).
For direct descent to Teresa from the largest number of children of a single individual, we believe the current record-holder is Isabel (also called Elizabeth) de Vermandois (1081-1147). (Descent from this individual is sufficiently widespread that genealogist Douglas Richardson once jokingly asserted the existence of an exclusive lineage organization called the Society of Non-Descendants of Isabel de Vermandois.) By her first husband Robert, Count of Meulan (1046-1118), Isabel had eight children; by her second husband William de Warenne, 2nd Earl of Surrey (1080-1138) she had five. Teresa is descended from four of the first set: Waleran, Count of Meulan (1104-1166), Robert, 2nd Earl of Leicester (1104-1168; twin to Waleran), Isabel de Beaumont (d. after 1172), and Maud of Meulan (d. after 1189); and from four of the second: William de Warenne, 3rd Earl of Surrey (1119-1148), Reynold de Warenne (1126-1179), Gundred de Warenne (d. after 1156) (through one child of her first marriage and one of her second), and Ada de Warenne (d. 1178).
It's probably not possible to have hundreds of documented 17th- and 18th-century colonial ancestors and avoid being distantly related to several US presidents. The Jefferson connection is mentioned above; Teresa has common ancestors with at least a dozen more. To the best of our knowledge Teresa's closest presidential connection is to Herbert Hoover, to whom she's a fourth cousin three times removed, via their shared ancestors the 18th-century Pennsylvania Quaker couple John Haworth (1717-1776) and Mary Garner (b. 1729), who were 3X-great grandparents of Hoover and 6X-great grandparents of Teresa. By contrast, her most recent known common ancestors with Barack Obama are Thomas le Grosvenor (1377-1429), and his wife Joan de Venables. Meanwhile, Patrick is less than thrilled to discover that his sole speck of New England ancestry--Nicholas Wallingford (d. 1681) and his father-in-law Henry Travers (1610-1650)--makes him a distant cousin to both of the presidents Bush, and also to Richard Milhous Nixon. We are relieved to be unaware of any genealogical connection to the latest inhabitant of the White House. So far.
As for crowned heads, anybody descended from Olive Welby, William Wentworth, Margaret Wyatt, and Alice Freeman is descended from a lot of them, mostly people who lived before 1200 A.D. The most recent monarch from whom Teresa descends is Edward I of England (1239-1307), followed closely by Philippe III of France (1245-1285). Don't get too excited; it's been argued that as much as sixty to eighty percent of the population of modern Britain is descended from Edward I. And of course we are all descended from Charlemagne.
In his Pedigree and Progress: Essays in the Genealogical Interpretation of History (London: Phillimore & Co., 1975), the late Anthony Wagner, Garter King of Arms, presented a pedigree he called "Atlantic to Pacific, 1274." In brief, Charles II (1254-1309), king of Naples, Sicily, and Jerusalem, was a nephew of several TNH ancestors, including Louis IX, king of France; Louis IX's wife Margaret of Provence; and Eleanor of Provence, wife of Henry III, king of England. Charles II's sister-in-law Anna of Hungary, sister of his wife Maria, married Andronicus II Palaeologus (d. 1332), emperor of Byzantium, whose half-sister (by his father's mistress) Maria Palaiologina (d. 1308) (popularly called St. Mary of the Mongols) married Abaka (d. 1282), second Ilkhan of Persia, son of Hulagu, first Ilkhan of Persia, brother of Kubla Khan (1215-1294), Emperor of China, both Hulagu and Kubla being grandsons of Genghis Khan (~1162-1227). "Thus in five years and through only eight persons a genealogical bridge was built across the Eurasian land mass from the Pacific to the Atlantic ocean."
Friends of ours in the subculture of science fiction and fantasy will be entirely unastonished to know that Teresa shares a sixteenth-century ancestor, Dr. Rev. Edward Bulkeley (1540-1621), rector of Odell, Bedfordshire, with bookseller and convention organizer Tom Whitmore, and editor and novelist Tappan King. Among the many other Bulkeley descendants are Jay Gould, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Macmillan CEO John Turner Sargent, Jr., the Bush presidents, John Kerry, John Huntsman, Sarah Palin, and the inventor of the World-Wide Web, Tim Berners-Lee.
Also unsurprisingly, given Teresa's extensive ancestry in 17th-century Rhode Island, she shares several ancestors with the author, essayist, and racist H. P. Lovecraft (1890-1937). Via James Babcock (1641-1698) and Jane Brown (d. 1718), she and Lovecraft are seventh cousins twice removed. Other common ancestors between TNH and HPL are Tristram Dodge (~1607-1683) and his wife Anne (d. ~1686), and Thomas Hazard (~1610-1677) and his wife Martha (d. 1669). It's interesting to note that because of cousins marrying cousins, Lovecraft was in fact doubly-descended from each of these couples. Cthulhu fhtagn.
Teresa has a pair of startlingly recent common ancestors with Laura (Wightman) Hayden, wife of Patrick's brother Benjamin. Noticed by Laura, a sharp-eyed genealogist herself, they're Samuel Yeomans (1655-1704) of Massachusetts and Connecticut, and Mary Ellis (1657-?) of Connecticut, and they're 7X-great grandparents of Laura and 9X-great grandparents of Teresa.