The most recent 20 comments posted to Making Light by csmaccath:

Show all comments by csmaccath.

Posted on entry $9,695 New Age sweat lodge session kills 2, injures 19 ::: October 16, 2009, 12:28 PM:
What's troubling to me as a Pagan is the notion that difficult times motivate spiritual searching, and both the times and the quest are motivated by deep vulnerability. I read about this when it happened and was appalled by it all; the huckster, the PRICE (oh, my Gods!), and the stupidity surrounding the sweat ceremony itself. Truly, this person was a charlatan who had little knowledge of what he was doing, physically or otherwise, except as it pertained to taking money from vulnerable people. Very upsetting.
Posted on entry The will of man made visible ::: August 23, 2007, 05:48 PM:
I've read most of Rand's fiction, most of her essays and a number of her letters and found everything I read stimulating, even when I didn't agree with it, which was often (I'm a progressive Democrat with strong socialist tendencies).

One of the things I enjoyed most about her work was her astute use of personality types as character models. I knew who Ellsworth Toohey was the moment he entered the story, and seeing him there helped me to better understand people I had known in life. The same was true with many other characters in her work. Granted, both Howard Roark and John Galt are a bit two-dimensional for my taste and often serve as mouthpieces for her ideology, but much like Milton's “Paradise Lost,†I think Rand's stories have more interesting devils than they do heroes.

I also think there's a great deal to be said for achievement and individuality, even though Rand says it much the way Zarathustra does and so is off-putting (“If you cannot help them to rise, help them to fall faster!â€). Still, I appreciated her challenge to the reader to work hard, enjoy the fruits of that work and not allow oneself to be dragged down into mediocrity or groupthink.

I am not comfortable with the “Randroids†I've met or read about (what a great turn of phrase!), since I think they've taken her work as a license to pillage and damn the consequences (and perhaps she did indeed mean it to be taken that way). But I confess that I do have my Reardonesque days, and on those days, I am more wholly an individual, and that can't be a bad thing.

Anyway, there's my two bits, or my apology for Ayn Rand, or whatever. =)

Comment statistics for csmaccath on the Making Light blog

YearNumber of comments posted
20091
20071

Total: 2 comments. View all these comments on a single page.