The most recent 20 comments posted to Making Light by Renee:

Show all comments by Renee.

Posted on entry The General Speaks ::: October 14, 2007, 02:57 PM:
Bruce Cohen @ 21, Patrick @ 27: Could the statement "The original idea of a citizen army was that most citizens would have an understanding of the military by being in it for awhile; this hasn't worked well for some time because even the citizens who have enlisted for a term aren't in the same position as career soldiers and often never do get to understand them" be related to the facts "100,000 enlisted soldiers out of 250,000 available men" be related by the ratio of how many men you would have in your circle of close acquaintances who have any experience of military life?

I'm thinking here that in a population of 250,000 where 100,000 have such experience, then if you have 25 acquaintances who you might consider 'close', 10 of them would have experience in the military. Compare the current numbers: a population of 165 million men (or so) and a standing army of... what? 2 million? Five million? It certainly isn't anywhere close to 66 million.

Yes, I'm ignoring women in the military. No, I am not a mathematician, but I can wave my hands in the air and pretend. It's kind of fun.

Comment statistics for Renee on the Making Light blog

YearNumber of comments posted
20071

Total: 1 comments. View all these comments on a single page.