The most recent 20 comments posted to Electrolite by Greg:

Show all comments by Greg.

Posted on entry The past isn't dead; it's not even past. ::: January 25, 2004, 10:03 PM:
Ah, yes, The Pope versus the Puritan, and a descendant of the Holy Roman Emperor as referee. Marvellous stuff, and one of the weirdest footnotes in modern European history.

The Seventeenth Century is clearly alive and well in County Antrim.

As for the amazement that a Hapsburg should be playing a role in European politics even now, maybe we shouldn't be so surprised. This sort of thing happens surprisingly often; Gebhardt von Moltke, Germany's top man in NATO, is a descendant of Bismarck's Field Marshall, of the rather less talented successor to Schlieffen in the German High Command, and of a count who opposed the Nazis and was executed for doing so. Blue blood there, I feel.
Posted on entry Back when they didn't even try to hide it. ::: August 30, 2003, 09:22 PM:
Sorry. I should have added that his ideas weren't adopted by the state once independence was achieved. Even now we still have much the same exam-orientated soul-destroying system we inherited from the British.
Posted on entry Back when they didn't even try to hide it. ::: August 30, 2003, 09:21 PM:
I've found this debate interesting, because I know that in turn-of-the-century Ireland similar views were expressed about our education system.

Our system was a British offshoot, and some, notably Patrick Pearse, felt that its sole purpose was to crush independence of spirit and to produce drones, the best of whom would be equipped only to work for the British Civil Service, while the less fortunate ones would be stuck with lives of agricultural drudgery or forced to emigrate.

(Whether such effects were intended or not is a different matter.)

Pearse, who became something of a plaster saint in newly Independent Ireland but is now regarded in a rather more jaundiced way, wrote a book called "The Murder Machine" about this very point and founded his own bilingual school to attempt to change this.

It was his failure to change the system peacefully that drove him to become such a prominent figure in our independence struggle.

Pearse may have been narcissistic and obsessed with a notion of blood-sacrifice, but I still find it interesting to think that somebody would have been willing to lead a rebellion with the primary aim of reforming the education system.

Comment statistics for Greg on the Electrolite blog

YearNumber of comments posted
20041
20032

Total: 3 comments. View all these comments on a single page.