The most recent 20 comments posted to Making Light by Matt:

Show all comments by Matt.

Posted on entry Why, yes, that is odd ::: November 04, 2004, 02:26 PM:
Does anybody have a good reason why you don't divide the electoral college votes for a state based on the proportion of votes each candidate receives within that state? As it stands, you can have a state with 17 votes that gets a 51% return for, say, Mr Monkey-brains, and all 17 votes go to him, when his opponent Mrs Cheesecake-face got 48.5% of the vote. How is that fair?

At least here in the UK we do it with smaller divisions, so although you can win a seat with well under 50% of the votes (depending on how many candidates are standing), it only decides one seat, not seventeen of the things. Strikes me as a simple change which would not make the system perfect, but would improve it considerably - and knock out a lot of this 'swing state' rubbish too.

Comment statistics for Matt on the Making Light blog

YearNumber of comments posted
20041

Total: 1 comments. View all these comments on a single page.