The most recent 20 comments posted to Electrolite by sGreer:

Show all comments by sGreer.

Posted on entry Delicate sensibilities. ::: March 07, 2005, 09:40 PM:
Crap. All I can say is: crap. Insert shocked voice here. I'm with Ben on this one--if they ran that on television, they might come dangerously close to restoring my faith in their knowledge that the power of the media might actually be used for good.

I mean, I've seen things that kick ya, but this didn't just kick ya in the teeth but in the gut. As a friend just pointed out, we don't have a problem with landmines in the US. (Well, depends. Been to former munitions dumps recently? We've got one in the suburbs of DC, now a lovely little community...) But we could use our power for good, I think. If the US raised its voice about landmines, too, who knows...

Don't know if that commercial would actually prompt such, but it's definitely chilling. Frankly, though, I think the danger with it is that the intense visceral reaction prompts a backlash: that wouldn't happen here! And people can turn away in relief, shoving down their original heart-rent reaction. Randomly (while recovering), I wonder if this reaction would change if it were kids playing soccer--same everything--but the voices were all in Korean. Or Hindu. Or Afrikaans. Something that says: these kids look like your kids, but this is "someplace else"--yet the parents' reactions are just like what you'd feel. So you're not seeing 'yourself' on the screen but really someone 'who loves their kids just like you'. Does that make sense to anyone other than me?

Got to give people a little distance, or they'll just run away, unfortunately, because that commercial really *hurt* to watch.

Comment statistics for sGreer on the Electrolite blog

YearNumber of comments posted
20051

Total: 1 comments. View all these comments on a single page.