Go to Making Light's front page.
Forward to next post: Open thread 223
Subscribe (via RSS) to this post's comment thread. (What does this mean? Here's a quick introduction.)
I largely gave up political blogging after November 8, 2016, when it became obvious that I have no idea what I’m talking about. I still don’t think anyone should pay any attention to what I think.
If you’re still reading, here are some of the things I recently thought were smart. Keep in mind that I’m an idiot.
Politics is for Power, Not Consumption, by Eitan Hersh. The bullshit performative stuff we do online isn’t politics, it’s just cosplay. “If you feel unfulfilled, melancholy, paralyzed by the sadness of the news and depth of our political problems, there is an alternative: actually doing politics. Citizens who want to empower their political values would be better off if they spent less time consuming politics as at-home amateurs and instead fell in line to help strengthen organizations and leaders. Rather than kibitzing with their social media friends, they could adopt some of the spirit of the party regulars, counting votes and building interpersonal relationships in their neighborhoods.”
Twitter thread by Jonathan Smucker, author of Hegemony How-To: A Roadmap for Radicals, which I’m reading and which is so far very good. “Being right wins you exactly nothing if you have no power.” “If you don’t choose your battles, your opponents will choose them for you.” “Revelations of misdeeds of the powerful induce only popular resignation if there is no viable counter-power to take advantage of the opening.” More.
Jane McAlevey, How to Organize Your Friends and Family on Thanksgiving. Step by step, how to talk to normal human beings without being the sanctimonious leftist prick everybody hates. Not coincidentally, written by a brilliant modern union organizer. I’m reading her No Shortcuts: Organizing for Power in the New Gilded Age and it’s terrific.
We Have to Take the Roses Seriously: Talking to Nathan J. Robinson. Interview with the very smart editor and publisher of the wonderfully-named Current Affairs, whose writing I’ve been generally bingeing on. “That great Terry Eagleton quote comes to mind, describing a socialist as ‘just someone who is unable to get over his or her astonishment that most people who have lived and died have spent lives of wretched, fruitless, unremitting toil.’ So I’d begin from that kind of disgust with certain features of the world, certain things that happen to some of us, certain ways that workers get treated. If we can agree that people should meaningfully participate in the decisions that affect their lives, then ‘Do you like the fact that if you drop below packing some set number of boxes per hour, a robot will fire you?’ they probably would say: ‘No, that’s not a process I personally would have established.’”
Hoping for hope. Happy new year.
I have still not recovered from the sense of unreality, but I've become resigned to the notion that this is the world I'm living in now, and for as long as I can manage to stay living.
So... onward, I guess.
The last four years have felt like at least a decade.
A brief comment on your postscript: whatever Safari for Mac's problem was seems to have been solved. I had no trouble seeing these comments on my desktop computer.
Turns out to be an effect of 1Blocker, Apple-approved ad-blocker add-on for Safari. To fix it, whitelist nielsenhayden.com, because that was obvious, obviously. The web in 2020 sucks beyond belief.
It has become obvious to me in recent years that I'm an outlier, both politically and in other respects: some people should not be allowed to run with scissors, or engage in politics, and I am one of them.
But looking at the dead-eyed neofascist grifters currently running governments worldwide, I can't say they're any better.
If Rick Perlstein couldn't see Trump coming, I think you can be forgiven the same oversight.
Keep in mind that Trump voters are, well, maybe not quite outliers, but in the minority.
The official federal election report for 2016 (PDF here) says the Census Bureau estimated the US voting-age population at 245.5 million in 2016. Of those, a bit more than 200 million were registered to vote (Politico news story), and 136,669,276 actually cast votes for president.
So here’s a breakdown of the voting-age population that year:
I'm happy to hear that the "crazification factor" of Trump voters was only 26%, and not the 27% that had been foretold:
John: You realize this leads to there being over 30 million crazy people in the US?Tyrone: Does that seem wrong?
John: ... a bit low, actually.
Chris@6 -- thanks for the pointer to that excellent Perlstein piece, which I missed the first time round.
8
Without seeing the write-ins, I wouldn't go that far.
Those comparisons of numbers are conspiracy-theory-level wrong, Jeremy (replying to Avram) -- the numbers look similar, but they're talking about completely different parts of the population under different measurement regimes that are just not comparable.
And it's rather a distraction from the main point I see PMH trying to make.
Thank you for posting this, Patrick.
Slowly reading through the linked articles.
I've been pondering volunteering for the Warren campaign, while also fighting my reflexive skepticism as to the effectiveness of things like canvassing and phone banking. (I hate people knocking on my door and calling me on the phone during campaign seasons. Why would others feel any differently about me? But I also recall that, if that AOC documentary is to be believed, she won largely on the strength of her ground game, and the success rate they quoted was something like 1/150.)
@12 Speaking as an activist of decades of experience, door knocking and phone banking are the most successful methods. They're expensive to do because they're labor-intensive, but they're absolutely the most effective. If you have the ability to volunteer, it would be a great use of your time.
That said, I encourage all new activists to let go of any pressure in trying to figure out the right way to help. Just help! You'll be making a difference, and the work will start to feel more comfortable as you get more experience. Change it up if you need to! If door knocking isn't possible, try phones, if not phones, write post-cards, if not post-cards, switch to envelope stuffing. If not a campaign, then a GOTV, if not GOTV, then a service charity. Whatever work you can find that suits you is good work to be doing.
IME, hobbyist culture spends a lot of time invalidating earnest effort. I encourage new activists to ignore any and all folks who denigrate whatever work you decide to try. Perfect is the enemy of the good. Just help. There's never enough hands for the work. Just help.
Venus: Thank you. That's...really helpful. Thank you.
Thank you to Venus for specific examples, and for being a voice of hopefulness.
I've had good results by asking for "tasks for introverts". If that baffles the organizer(s), I suggest data entry or one of the options that Venus listed.
PostcardsToVoters.org has been a comfortable fit for my energy level, and a boost to my spirits. Their FAQ page is very detailed.
Venus, #13, wrote: IME, hobbyist culture spends a lot of time invalidating earnest effort. I encourage new activists to ignore any and all folks who denigrate whatever work you decide to try. Perfect is the enemy of the good. Just help. There's never enough hands for the work. Just help.
I just wanted to re-post that, because it's great.
If I'm lucky, I'll listen to it and take its advice. Meanwhile I hope other people do.
(TNH and I turned out last night to demonstrate in front of our neighbor Chuck Schumer's Park Slope apartment. Because why should we let our prevaricating centrist senior senator, who happens to also be Senate Minority Leader, get pressured only by the Right.)
(Seriously, we did the exact same thing 17 years ago, in the runup to the Iraq invasion that Chuck ultimately voted for. Difference being, 17 years ago, we were kept across the street from the Schumer apartment building, and our crowd consisted of a half-dozen crusty old Trots and maybe ten or twenty shell-shocked I-can't-believe-this-is-happening young white professionals. On 3 Jan 2020, it was hundreds of people, all of whom came out on less than a day's notice. We may all fail just as badly -- power doesn't really give a shit -- but we'll have lots more useful networky conversations while we're failing. For instance, T and I met (and fanboyed) the eminent lefty journalist David Klion, which made the effort worthwhile all by itself.)
I was going to say something here, but Venus said it at least as well as I could. Hear, hear!
I'm not sure what Charlie Stross means by 'should not be allowed to [..] engage in politics'. He probably wouldn't be a great candidate for most positions, and not my first choice to run a national campaign (No offense; I wouldn't be my first or hundredth choice either), but that's not the only way of engaging in politics. Phone-banking, door-knocking, contributing cash, hosting a yard sign, anything helps. The amount of volunteer professional assistance that campaigns need is sadly always less than the amount that people want to give, but it's possible that there's a campaign that could use the help of a real professional writer, even if it's just proof-reading press releases.
Charlie writes about politics on his blog. I think that counts for quite a lot. And he gets invited to speak about the future. One would hope that thinking about the future is part of politics. Charlie is a good writer and speaker. His politics are sensible and caring. I wish that did not make him so much of an outlier.
Warren Selfies Twitter thread: Interesting parallax on the McAlevey Thanksgiving link in the OP.
I remember coming here to read accounts of the First in the nation's first in the nation primary at Dixville Notch. Reported by Jim Macdonald (who, according to google search for name and this site, has not been posting recently)
Very interested to get a firsthand report from there a few hours from now. I'll circle back here. And check twitter.
The results from Dixville Notch, via WMUR:
Bloomberg 2, Pete 1, Bernie 1
I'd actually seen different results in my Apple News feed this morning, with significantnly more voters. Sanders first (8), Warren and Buttigeig second (4), Klobuchar, Biden and Bloomberg trailing but still getting votes.
I also came here hoping for Dixville commentary. I miss this site in general.
Hrmfph. Planning on caucusing tomorrow for a Dem challenger to Cory Gardner. (First time I've ever done this.) Wish me spoons....
Bless you, Jacque, and everyone with the strength and determination to caucus, or to stand in line to vote in a primary; we need every one of you.
I'm spoiled (read: privileged): my (paper) primary ballot came to my house several weeks ago, and I dropped it off at work a week later.
I'm hoping the caucus eats only five hours out of my day...?
Okay! Ah dun mah civic dooty! Looks like I'm going to the county caucus in two weeks. Let's please have that be the end of it for me, pretty please...?
Jacque (28): I think this is a candidate for the Dreadful Phrases thread: I read that as "county cactus" the first time.
It sounds as though the county cactus has just been Hi Jacked, or was it cactus jacked?
Just as an afterthought:
Hi Jacque!
g,d&rvvvvf
3:O)>
Just don't ever do that when we're on an airplane!!
XD
Bret Stephens: Covid-19: A Look Back From 2025.
Once power is given, it's hard to reclaim....
thanks to sharing. thats grat idea
Comments containing more than seven URLs will be held for approval. If you want to comment on a thread that's been closed, please post to the most recent "Open Thread" discussion.
You can subscribe (via RSS) to this particular comment thread. (If this option is baffling, here's a quick introduction.)
HTML Tags:
<strong>Strong</strong> = Strong
<em>Emphasized</em> = Emphasized
<a href="http://www.url.com">Linked text</a> = Linked text
Spelling reference:
Tolkien. Minuscule. Gandhi. Millennium. Delany. Embarrassment. Publishers Weekly. Occurrence. Asimov. Weird. Connoisseur. Accommodate. Hierarchy. Deity. Etiquette. Pharaoh. Teresa. Its. Macdonald. Nielsen Hayden. It's. Fluorosphere. Barack. More here.