| | 1. William Elias Butler , b. 8 Nov 1837, Tennessee , d. 1 Aug 1878, Gibson, Gibson, Tennessee (Age 40 years) | | | 2. James Madison Butler , b. 1840, Tennessee  | | | 3. John Franklin Butler , b. 11 Dec 1841, Marion, Illinois , d. Aug 1906, Gibson, Gibson, Tennessee (Age 64 years) | | | 4. Thomas Van Buren Butler , b. 22 Aug 1843, Marion, Illinois , d. 30 May 1902, Jasper, Walker, Alabama (Age 58 years) | | | 5. Benjamin R Butler , b. 8 Dec 1846, Gibson, Gibson, Tennessee , d. 3 Mar 1927, Gibson, Gibson, Tennessee (Age 80 years) | | | 6. Sarah Ann Butler , b. 1848, Tennessee , d. 1888, Elm Springs, Washington, Arkansas (Age 40 years) | | + | 7. Mary Frances "Fannie" Butler , b. 8 Aug 1851, Coffee County, Tennessee , d. 1 Dec 1926, Gibson County, Tennessee (Age 75 years) | |